ONOS-1286: Backing out chages to use ECMap for dist flow rule store backups

Change-Id: I93a60ef183aa335fecf63b97d300830369d2b9d7

ONOS-1286: Backing out chages to use ECMap for dist flow rule store backups
Change-Id: I93a60ef183aa335fecf63b97d300830369d2b9d7
Madan Jampani · Gerrit Code Review
Commit b0a3dd6136a448ea041e0aab955d134633edea57 b0a3dd61 1 parent 9a89c533
Showing 1 changed file with 225 additions and 130 deletions
core/store/dist/src/main/java/org/onosproject/store/flow/impl/DistributedFlowRuleStore.java
--- a/core/store/dist/src/main/java/org/onosproject/store/flow/impl/DistributedFlowRuleStore.java
View file @b0a3dd6
+++ b/core/store/dist/src/main/java/org/onosproject/store/flow/impl/DistributedFlowRuleStore.java
View file @b0a3dd6
-/*
+ /*
  * Copyright 2014 Open Networking Laboratory
  *
  * Licensed under the Apache License, Version 2.0 (the "License");
@@ -15,11 +15,15 @@
  */
 package org.onosproject.store.flow.impl;
+import com.google.common.cache.CacheBuilder;
+import com.google.common.cache.CacheLoader;
+import com.google.common.cache.LoadingCache;
 import com.google.common.collect.ImmutableList;
 import com.google.common.collect.Iterables;
 import com.google.common.collect.Maps;
 import com.google.common.collect.Sets;
-import org.apache.commons.lang.math.RandomUtils;
+import com.hazelcast.core.IMap;
+
 import org.apache.felix.scr.annotations.Activate;
 import org.apache.felix.scr.annotations.Component;
 import org.apache.felix.scr.annotations.Deactivate;
@@ -28,7 +32,9 @@ import org.apache.felix.scr.annotations.Property;
 import org.apache.felix.scr.annotations.Reference;
 import org.apache.felix.scr.annotations.ReferenceCardinality;
 import org.apache.felix.scr.annotations.Service;
+import org.onlab.util.BoundedThreadPool;
 import org.onlab.util.KryoNamespace;
+import org.onlab.util.NewConcurrentHashMap;
 import org.onosproject.cfg.ComponentConfigService;
 import org.onosproject.cluster.ClusterService;
 import org.onosproject.cluster.NodeId;
@@ -36,7 +42,6 @@ import org.onosproject.core.CoreService;
 import org.onosproject.core.IdGenerator;
 import org.onosproject.net.Device;
 import org.onosproject.net.DeviceId;
-import org.onosproject.net.device.DeviceClockService;
 import org.onosproject.net.device.DeviceService;
 import org.onosproject.net.flow.CompletedBatchOperation;
 import org.onosproject.net.flow.DefaultFlowEntry;
@@ -55,19 +60,15 @@ import org.onosproject.net.flow.FlowRuleService;
 import org.onosproject.net.flow.FlowRuleStore;
 import org.onosproject.net.flow.FlowRuleStoreDelegate;
 import org.onosproject.net.flow.StoredFlowEntry;
-import org.onosproject.store.AbstractStore;
 import org.onosproject.store.cluster.messaging.ClusterCommunicationService;
 import org.onosproject.store.cluster.messaging.ClusterMessage;
 import org.onosproject.store.cluster.messaging.ClusterMessageHandler;
-import org.onosproject.store.ecmap.EventuallyConsistentMap;
-import org.onosproject.store.ecmap.EventuallyConsistentMapImpl;
 import org.onosproject.store.flow.ReplicaInfo;
 import org.onosproject.store.flow.ReplicaInfoEvent;
 import org.onosproject.store.flow.ReplicaInfoEventListener;
 import org.onosproject.store.flow.ReplicaInfoService;
-import org.onosproject.store.impl.ClockService;
+import org.onosproject.store.hz.AbstractHazelcastStore;
-import org.onosproject.store.impl.MastershipBasedTimestamp;
+import org.onosproject.store.hz.SMap;
-import org.onosproject.store.serializers.KryoNamespaces;
 import org.onosproject.store.serializers.KryoSerializer;
 import org.onosproject.store.serializers.StoreSerializer;
 import org.onosproject.store.serializers.impl.DistributedStoreSerializers;
@@ -75,12 +76,14 @@ import org.osgi.service.component.ComponentContext;
 import org.slf4j.Logger;
 import java.io.IOException;
+import java.util.ArrayList;
 import java.util.Arrays;
-import java.util.Collection;
 import java.util.Collections;
 import java.util.Dictionary;
+import java.util.HashSet;
 import java.util.List;
 import java.util.Map;
+import java.util.Map.Entry;
 import java.util.Set;
 import java.util.concurrent.ConcurrentHashMap;
 import java.util.concurrent.ConcurrentMap;
@@ -93,8 +96,9 @@ import java.util.concurrent.TimeUnit;
 import java.util.concurrent.TimeoutException;
 import java.util.stream.Collectors;
+import static com.google.common.base.Preconditions.checkNotNull;
+import static org.apache.commons.lang3.concurrent.ConcurrentUtils.createIfAbsentUnchecked;
 import static com.google.common.base.Strings.isNullOrEmpty;
-import static org.apache.felix.scr.annotations.ReferenceCardinality.MANDATORY_UNARY;
 import static org.onlab.util.Tools.get;
 import static org.onlab.util.Tools.groupedThreads;
 import static org.onosproject.net.flow.FlowRuleEvent.Type.RULE_REMOVED;
@@ -107,13 +111,13 @@ import static org.slf4j.LoggerFactory.getLogger;
 @Component(immediate = true)
 @Service
 public class DistributedFlowRuleStore
-        extends AbstractStore<FlowRuleBatchEvent, FlowRuleStoreDelegate>
+        extends AbstractHazelcastStore<FlowRuleBatchEvent, FlowRuleStoreDelegate>
         implements FlowRuleStore {
     private final Logger log = getLogger(getClass());
     private static final int MESSAGE_HANDLER_THREAD_POOL_SIZE = 8;
-    private static final boolean DEFAULT_BACKUP_ENABLED = false;
+    private static final boolean DEFAULT_BACKUP_ENABLED = true;
     private static final long FLOW_RULE_STORE_TIMEOUT_MILLIS = 5000;
     @Property(name = "msgHandlerPoolSize", intValue = MESSAGE_HANDLER_THREAD_POOL_SIZE,
@@ -124,7 +128,10 @@ public class DistributedFlowRuleStore
             label = "Indicates whether backups are enabled or not")
     private boolean backupEnabled = DEFAULT_BACKUP_ENABLED;
-    private InternalFlowTable flowTable;
+    private InternalFlowTable flowTable = new InternalFlowTable();
+
+    /*private final ConcurrentMap<DeviceId, ConcurrentMap<FlowId, Set<StoredFlowEntry>>>
+            flowEntries = new ConcurrentHashMap<>();*/
     @Reference(cardinality = ReferenceCardinality.MANDATORY_UNARY)
     protected ReplicaInfoService replicaInfoManager;
@@ -139,18 +146,24 @@ public class DistributedFlowRuleStore
     protected DeviceService deviceService;
     @Reference(cardinality = ReferenceCardinality.MANDATORY_UNARY)
-    protected DeviceClockService deviceClockService;
-
-    @Reference(cardinality = ReferenceCardinality.MANDATORY_UNARY)
     protected CoreService coreService;
-    @Reference(cardinality = MANDATORY_UNARY)
+    @Reference(cardinality = ReferenceCardinality.MANDATORY_UNARY)
     protected ComponentConfigService configService;
     private Map<Long, NodeId> pendingResponses = Maps.newConcurrentMap();
+    // Cache of SMaps used for backup data.  each SMap contain device flow table
+    private LoadingCache<DeviceId, SMap<FlowId, ImmutableList<StoredFlowEntry>>> smaps;
+
     private ExecutorService messageHandlingExecutor;
+    private final ExecutorService backupExecutors =
+            BoundedThreadPool.newSingleThreadExecutor(groupedThreads("onos/flow", "async-backups"));
+            //Executors.newSingleThreadExecutor(groupedThreads("onos/flow", "async-backups"));
+
+    private boolean syncBackup = false;
+
     protected static final StoreSerializer SERIALIZER = new KryoSerializer() {
         @Override
         protected void setupKryoPool() {
@@ -170,11 +183,16 @@ public class DistributedFlowRuleStore
     @Activate
     public void activate(ComponentContext context) {
         configService.registerProperties(getClass());
-
+        super.serializer = SERIALIZER;
-        flowTable = new InternalFlowTable().withBackupsEnabled(backupEnabled);
+        super.theInstance = storeService.getHazelcastInstance();
         idGenerator = coreService.getIdGenerator(FlowRuleService.FLOW_OP_TOPIC);
+        // Cache to create SMap on demand
+        smaps = CacheBuilder.newBuilder()
+                .softValues()
+                .build(new SMapLoader());
+
         final NodeId local = clusterService.getLocalNode().id();
         messageHandlingExecutor = Executors.newFixedThreadPool(
@@ -212,7 +230,7 @@ public class DistributedFlowRuleStore
             public void handle(ClusterMessage message) {
                 DeviceId deviceId = SERIALIZER.decode(message.payload());
                 log.trace("Received get flow entries request for {} from {}", deviceId, message.sender());
-                Set<StoredFlowEntry> flowEntries = flowTable.getFlowEntries(deviceId);
+                Set<FlowEntry> flowEntries = flowTable.getFlowEntries(deviceId);
                 try {
                     message.respond(SERIALIZER.encode(flowEntries));
                 } catch (IOException e) {
@@ -282,8 +300,6 @@ public class DistributedFlowRuleStore
         if (newPoolSize != msgHandlerPoolSize || newBackupEnabled != backupEnabled) {
             msgHandlerPoolSize = newPoolSize;
             backupEnabled = newBackupEnabled;
-            // reconfigure the store
-            flowTable.withBackupsEnabled(backupEnabled);
             ExecutorService oldMsgHandler = messageHandlingExecutor;
             messageHandlingExecutor = Executors.newFixedThreadPool(
                     msgHandlerPoolSize, groupedThreads("onos/store/flow", "message-handlers"));
@@ -297,6 +313,7 @@ public class DistributedFlowRuleStore
                  prefix, msgHandlerPoolSize, backupEnabled);
     }
+
     // This is not a efficient operation on a distributed sharded
     // flow store. We need to revisit the need for this operation or at least
     // make it device specific.
@@ -354,7 +371,7 @@ public class DistributedFlowRuleStore
         }
         if (replicaInfo.master().get().equals(clusterService.getLocalNode().id())) {
-            return flowTable.getFlowEntries(deviceId).stream().collect(Collectors.toSet());
+            return flowTable.getFlowEntries(deviceId);
         }
         log.trace("Forwarding getFlowEntries to {}, which is the primary (master) for device {}",
@@ -451,6 +468,7 @@ public class DistributedFlowRuleStore
                     new CompletedBatchOperation(true, Collections.emptySet(), did)));
             return;
         }
+        updateBackup(did, currentOps);
         notifyDelegate(FlowRuleBatchEvent.requested(new
                            FlowRuleBatchRequest(operation.id(),
@@ -489,6 +507,23 @@ public class DistributedFlowRuleStore
         ).filter(op -> op != null).collect(Collectors.toSet());
     }
+    private void updateBackup(DeviceId deviceId, final Set<FlowRuleBatchEntry> entries) {
+        if (!backupEnabled) {
+            return;
+        }
+
+        Future<?> backup = backupExecutors.submit(new UpdateBackup(deviceId, entries));
+
+        if (syncBackup) {
+            // wait for backup to complete
+            try {
+                backup.get();
+            } catch (InterruptedException | ExecutionException e) {
+                log.error("Failed to create backups", e);
+            }
+        }
+    }
+
     @Override
     public void deleteFlowRule(FlowRule rule) {
         storeBatch(
@@ -504,7 +539,7 @@ public class DistributedFlowRuleStore
         ReplicaInfo replicaInfo = replicaInfoManager.getReplicaInfoFor(rule.deviceId());
         final NodeId localId = clusterService.getLocalNode().id();
         if (localId.equals(replicaInfo.master().orNull())) {
-            return addOrUpdateFlowRuleInternal((StoredFlowEntry) rule);
+            return addOrUpdateFlowRuleInternal(rule);
         }
         log.warn("Tried to update FlowRule {} state,"
@@ -512,7 +547,10 @@ public class DistributedFlowRuleStore
         return null;
     }
-    private FlowRuleEvent addOrUpdateFlowRuleInternal(StoredFlowEntry rule) {
+    private FlowRuleEvent addOrUpdateFlowRuleInternal(FlowEntry rule) {
+        final DeviceId did = rule.deviceId();
+
+
         // check if this new rule is an update to an existing entry
         StoredFlowEntry stored = flowTable.getFlowEntry(rule);
         if (stored != null) {
@@ -521,15 +559,21 @@ public class DistributedFlowRuleStore
             stored.setPackets(rule.packets());
             if (stored.state() == FlowEntryState.PENDING_ADD) {
                 stored.setState(FlowEntryState.ADDED);
+                FlowRuleBatchEntry entry =
+                        new FlowRuleBatchEntry(FlowRuleOperation.ADD, stored);
+                updateBackup(did, Sets.newHashSet(entry));
                 return new FlowRuleEvent(Type.RULE_ADDED, rule);
             }
             return new FlowRuleEvent(Type.RULE_UPDATED, rule);
         }
         // TODO: Confirm if this behavior is correct. See SimpleFlowRuleStore
+        // TODO: also update backup if the behavior is correct.
         flowTable.add(rule);
+
         return null;
+
     }
     @Override
@@ -570,6 +614,9 @@ public class DistributedFlowRuleStore
         final DeviceId deviceId = rule.deviceId();
         // This is where one could mark a rule as removed and still keep it in the store.
         final boolean removed = flowTable.remove(deviceId, rule); //flowEntries.remove(deviceId, rule);
+        FlowRuleBatchEntry entry =
+                new FlowRuleBatchEntry(FlowRuleOperation.REMOVE, rule);
+        updateBackup(deviceId, Sets.newHashSet(entry));
         if (removed) {
             return new FlowRuleEvent(RULE_REMOVED, rule);
         } else {
@@ -596,10 +643,35 @@ public class DistributedFlowRuleStore
         }
     }
+    private void loadFromBackup(final DeviceId did) {
+        if (!backupEnabled) {
+            return;
+        }
+        log.info("We are now the master for {}. Will load flow rules from backup", did);
+        try {
+            log.debug("Loading FlowRules for {} from backups", did);
+            SMap<FlowId, ImmutableList<StoredFlowEntry>> backupFlowTable = smaps.get(did);
+            for (Entry<FlowId, ImmutableList<StoredFlowEntry>> e
+                    : backupFlowTable.entrySet()) {
+
+                log.trace("loading {}", e.getValue());
+                for (StoredFlowEntry entry : e.getValue()) {
+                    flowTable.getFlowEntriesById(entry).remove(entry);
+                    flowTable.getFlowEntriesById(entry).add(entry);
+
+
+                }
+            }
+        } catch (ExecutionException e) {
+            log.error("Failed to load backup flowtable for {}", did, e);
+        }
+    }
+
     private void removeFromPrimary(final DeviceId did) {
         flowTable.clearDevice(did);
     }
+
     private final class OnStoreBatch implements ClusterMessageHandler {
         private final NodeId local;
@@ -616,11 +688,10 @@ public class DistributedFlowRuleStore
             ReplicaInfo replicaInfo = replicaInfoManager.getReplicaInfoFor(deviceId);
             if (!local.equals(replicaInfo.master().orNull())) {
-                Set<FlowRule> failures = operation.getOperations()
+                Set<FlowRule> failures = new HashSet<>(operation.size());
-                            .stream()
+                for (FlowRuleBatchEntry op : operation.getOperations()) {
-                            .map(FlowRuleBatchEntry::target)
+                    failures.add(op.target());
-                            .collect(Collectors.toSet());
+                }
-
                 CompletedBatchOperation allFailed = new CompletedBatchOperation(false, failures, deviceId);
                 // This node is no longer the master, respond as all failed.
                 // TODO: we might want to wrap response in envelope
@@ -641,6 +712,17 @@ public class DistributedFlowRuleStore
         }
     }
+    private final class SMapLoader
+            extends CacheLoader<DeviceId, SMap<FlowId, ImmutableList<StoredFlowEntry>>> {
+
+        @Override
+        public SMap<FlowId, ImmutableList<StoredFlowEntry>> load(DeviceId id)
+                throws Exception {
+            IMap<byte[], byte[]> map = theInstance.getMap("flowtable_" + id.toString());
+            return new SMap<FlowId, ImmutableList<StoredFlowEntry>>(map, SERIALIZER);
+        }
+    }
+
     private final class InternalReplicaInfoEventListener
             implements ReplicaInfoEventListener {
@@ -655,7 +737,7 @@ public class DistributedFlowRuleStore
                     if (local.equals(rInfo.master().orNull())) {
                         // This node is the new master, populate local structure
                         // from backup
-                        flowTable.loadFromBackup(did);
+                        loadFromBackup(did);
                     }
                     //else {
                         // This node is no longer the master holder,
@@ -672,133 +754,146 @@ public class DistributedFlowRuleStore
         }
     }
-    private class InternalFlowTable {
+    // Task to update FlowEntries in backup HZ store
+    private final class UpdateBackup implements Runnable {
-        private boolean backupsEnabled = true;
+        private final DeviceId deviceId;
+        private final Set<FlowRuleBatchEntry> ops;
+
+
+        public UpdateBackup(DeviceId deviceId,
+                            Set<FlowRuleBatchEntry> ops) {
+            this.deviceId = checkNotNull(deviceId);
+            this.ops = checkNotNull(ops);
-        /**
-         * Turns backups on or off.
-         * @param backupsEnabled whether backups should be enabled or not
-         * @return this instance
-         */
-        public InternalFlowTable withBackupsEnabled(boolean backupsEnabled) {
-            this.backupsEnabled = backupsEnabled;
-            return this;
-        }
-
-        private final Map<DeviceId, Map<FlowId, Set<StoredFlowEntry>>>
-                flowEntries = Maps.newConcurrentMap();
-
-        private final KryoNamespace.Builder flowSerializer = KryoNamespace.newBuilder()
-                .register(KryoNamespaces.API)
-                .register(MastershipBasedTimestamp.class);
-
-        private final ClockService<FlowId, StoredFlowEntry> clockService =
-                (flowId, flowEntry) ->
-                        (flowEntry == null) ? null : deviceClockService.getTimestamp(flowEntry.deviceId());
-
-        private final EventuallyConsistentMap<FlowId, StoredFlowEntry> backupMap =
-                new EventuallyConsistentMapImpl<>("flow-backup",
-                        clusterService,
-                        clusterCommunicator,
-                        flowSerializer,
-                        clockService,
-                        (key, flowEntry) -> getPeerNodes()).withTombstonesDisabled(true);
-
-        private Collection<NodeId> getPeerNodes() {
-            List<NodeId> nodes = clusterService.getNodes()
-                                    .stream()
-                                    .map(node -> node.id())
-                                    .filter(id -> !id.equals(clusterService.getLocalNode().id()))
-                                    .collect(Collectors.toList());
-
-            if (nodes.isEmpty()) {
-                return ImmutableList.of();
-            } else {
-                // get a random peer
-                return ImmutableList.of(nodes.get(RandomUtils.nextInt(nodes.size())));
-            }
         }
-        public void loadFromBackup(DeviceId deviceId) {
+        @Override
-            if (!backupsEnabled) {
+        public void run() {
-                return;
+            try {
+                log.trace("update backup {} {}", deviceId, ops
+                );
+                final SMap<FlowId, ImmutableList<StoredFlowEntry>> backupFlowTable = smaps.get(deviceId);
+
+
+                ops.stream().forEach(
+                        op -> {
+                            final FlowRule entry = op.target();
+                            final FlowId id = entry.id();
+                            ImmutableList<StoredFlowEntry> original = backupFlowTable.get(id);
+                            List<StoredFlowEntry> list = new ArrayList<>();
+                            if (original != null) {
+                                list.addAll(original);
+                            }
+                            list.remove(op.target());
+                            if (op.operator() == FlowRuleOperation.ADD) {
+                                list.add((StoredFlowEntry) entry);
+                            }
+
+                            ImmutableList<StoredFlowEntry> newValue = ImmutableList.copyOf(list);
+                            boolean success;
+                            if (original == null) {
+                                success = (backupFlowTable.putIfAbsent(id, newValue) == null);
+                            } else {
+                                success = backupFlowTable.replace(id, original, newValue);
+                            }
+                            if (!success) {
+                                log.error("Updating backup failed.");
+                            }
+
+                        }
+                );
+            } catch (ExecutionException e) {
+                log.error("Failed to write to backups", e);
             }
-            log.info("We are now the master for {}. Will load flow rules from backup", deviceId);
+
-
+        }
-            ConcurrentMap<FlowId, Set<StoredFlowEntry>> flowTable = new ConcurrentHashMap<>();
+    }
-
+
-            backupMap.values()
+    private class InternalFlowTable {
-                .stream()
+
-                .filter(entry -> entry.deviceId().equals(deviceId))
+        /*
-                .forEach(entry -> flowTable.computeIfPresent(entry.id(), (k, v) -> {
+            TODO: This needs to be cleaned up. Perhaps using the eventually consistent
-                    if (v == null) {
+            map when it supports distributed to a sequence of instances.
-                        return Sets.newHashSet(entry);
+         */
-                    } else {
+
-                        v.add(entry);
+
-                    }
+        private final ConcurrentMap<DeviceId, ConcurrentMap<FlowId, Set<StoredFlowEntry>>>
-                    return v;
+                flowEntries = new ConcurrentHashMap<>();
-                }));
+
-            flowEntries.putIfAbsent(deviceId, flowTable);
+
+        private NewConcurrentHashMap<FlowId, Set<StoredFlowEntry>> lazyEmptyFlowTable() {
+            return NewConcurrentHashMap.<FlowId, Set<StoredFlowEntry>>ifNeeded();
+        }
+
+        /**
+         * Returns the flow table for specified device.
+         *
+         * @param deviceId identifier of the device
+         * @return Map representing Flow Table of given device.
+         */
+        private ConcurrentMap<FlowId, Set<StoredFlowEntry>> getFlowTable(DeviceId deviceId) {
+            return createIfAbsentUnchecked(flowEntries,
+                                           deviceId, lazyEmptyFlowTable());
         }
         private Set<StoredFlowEntry> getFlowEntriesInternal(DeviceId deviceId, FlowId flowId) {
-            return flowEntries
+            final ConcurrentMap<FlowId, Set<StoredFlowEntry>> flowTable = getFlowTable(deviceId);
-                        .computeIfAbsent(deviceId, key -> Maps.newConcurrentMap())
+            Set<StoredFlowEntry> r = flowTable.get(flowId);
-                        .computeIfAbsent(flowId, k -> new CopyOnWriteArraySet<>());
+            if (r == null) {
+                final Set<StoredFlowEntry> concurrentlyAdded;
+                r = new CopyOnWriteArraySet<>();
+                concurrentlyAdded = flowTable.putIfAbsent(flowId, r);
+                if (concurrentlyAdded != null) {
+                    return concurrentlyAdded;
+                }
+            }
+            return r;
         }
         private StoredFlowEntry getFlowEntryInternal(FlowRule rule) {
-            return getFlowEntriesInternal(rule.deviceId(), rule.id())
+            for (StoredFlowEntry f : getFlowEntriesInternal(rule.deviceId(), rule.id())) {
-                .stream()
+                if (f.equals(rule)) {
-                .filter(element -> element.equals(rule))
+                    return f;
-                .findFirst()
+                }
-                .orElse(null);
+            }
+            return null;
         }
-        private Set<StoredFlowEntry> getFlowEntriesInternal(DeviceId deviceId) {
+        private Set<FlowEntry> getFlowEntriesInternal(DeviceId deviceId) {
-            Set<StoredFlowEntry> entries = Sets.newHashSet();
+            return getFlowTable(deviceId).values().stream()
-            flowEntries.computeIfAbsent(deviceId, key -> Maps.newConcurrentMap())
+                    .flatMap((list -> list.stream())).collect(Collectors.toSet());
-                        .values()
+
-                        .forEach(entries::addAll);
-            return entries;
         }
+
         public StoredFlowEntry getFlowEntry(FlowRule rule) {
             return getFlowEntryInternal(rule);
         }
-        public Set<StoredFlowEntry> getFlowEntries(DeviceId deviceId) {
+        public Set<FlowEntry> getFlowEntries(DeviceId deviceId) {
             return getFlowEntriesInternal(deviceId);
         }
-        public void add(StoredFlowEntry rule) {
+        public Set<StoredFlowEntry> getFlowEntriesById(FlowEntry entry) {
-            getFlowEntriesInternal(rule.deviceId(), rule.id()).add(rule);
+            return getFlowEntriesInternal(entry.deviceId(), entry.id());
-            if (backupsEnabled) {
+        }
-                try {
+
-                    backupMap.put(rule.id(), rule);
+        public void add(FlowEntry rule) {
-                } catch (Exception e) {
+            ((CopyOnWriteArraySet)
-                    log.warn("Failed to backup flow rule", e);
+                    getFlowEntriesInternal(rule.deviceId(), rule.id())).add(rule);
-                }
-            }
         }
         public boolean remove(DeviceId deviceId, FlowEntry rule) {
-            boolean status =
+            return ((CopyOnWriteArraySet)
-                    getFlowEntriesInternal(deviceId, rule.id()).remove(rule);
+                    getFlowEntriesInternal(deviceId, rule.id())).remove(rule);
-            if (backupsEnabled && status) {
+            //return flowEntries.remove(deviceId, rule);
-                try {
-                    backupMap.remove(rule.id(), (DefaultFlowEntry) rule);
-                } catch (Exception e) {
-                    log.warn("Failed to remove backup of flow rule", e);
-                }
-            }
-            return status;
         }
         public void clearDevice(DeviceId did) {
             flowEntries.remove(did);
-            // Flow entries should continue to remain in backup map.
         }
     }
+
+
 }